Why Is Last Tango in Paris Controversial?

By Alice Nichols

Last Tango in Paris is a 1972 French-Italian film directed by Bernardo Bertolucci and starring Marlon Brando and Maria Schneider. The movie tells the story of a recently widowed American man, Paul, who begins a sexual relationship with a young Parisian woman, Jeanne. However, the film’s depiction of sex and violence has led to controversy and criticism over the years.

Sexual Content

One reason why Last Tango in Paris is controversial is its explicit sexual content. The film features several graphic scenes that depict nudity and simulated sex acts between Brando and Schneider.

These scenes were considered shocking at the time of the film’s release. Many critics saw them as exploitative, particularly because Schneider was only 19 years old at the time of filming.

The Butter Scene

One particular scene that has garnered much attention is known as “the butter scene.” In this scene, Paul sodomizes Jeanne using butter as a lubricant.

This scene has been widely criticized for its depiction of sexual violence and non-consensual behavior. Bertolucci later admitted that he did not inform Schneider about the details of the scene beforehand, leading many to accuse him of exploiting the young actress.

Violence

Another reason why Last Tango in Paris is controversial is its depiction of violence. The film features several scenes that depict physical aggression between Paul and Jeanne. For example, in one scene, Paul slaps Jeanne across the face after she admits to having had an abortion.

Misogyny

Critics have also accused Last Tango in Paris of being misogynistic. Some argue that the film perpetuates harmful stereotypes about women by portraying them as submissive and objectified. Others have pointed out that Brando’s character is abusive towards Jeanne throughout much of the film.

Censorship

Last Tango in Paris has faced censorship in several countries over the years. In the United States, the film was initially given an X rating, which restricted it to adult audiences only. The film was eventually re-rated as NC-17 in 1997, which meant that no one under 17 could be admitted to see it.

Legacy

Despite its controversial reputation, Last Tango in Paris has had a significant impact on cinema and popular culture. The film’s frank depiction of sexuality paved the way for other movies to explore similar themes. It remains a critically acclaimed work of art and is considered a classic of 1970s cinema.

In conclusion, Last Tango in Paris is controversial for its depiction of explicit sexual content, violence, and misogyny. While the film’s legacy has been tarnished by these criticisms, it remains an important work of cinema that pushed boundaries and challenged societal norms.