Are Use It or Lose It Vacation Policies Legal?

By Michael Ferguson

If you’re an employee, you may be familiar with the concept of “use it or lose it” vacation policies. These policies require employees to use their vacation time within a certain timeframe or risk losing it altogether.

But are these policies legal Let’s take a closer look.

What is a Use It or Lose It Vacation Policy

A use it or lose it vacation policy is one that requires employees to use their allotted vacation time within a certain timeframe, typically by the end of the year. If they don’t use all of their vacation time by the deadline, they forfeit any unused time and won’t be compensated for it.

The Pros and Cons of Use It or Lose It Policies

On the surface, these policies seem like they could be beneficial for both employers and employees. Employers have an easier time managing their staffing needs when they know in advance when employees will be taking time off. These policies also encourage employees to take vacations, which can lead to increased productivity and job satisfaction.

However, there are some downsides to these policies as well. Employees may feel pressure to take vacations even when they don’t want to, simply because they don’t want to lose their accrued time off. Additionally, employees who are unable to take vacations due to work demands may end up losing out on valuable compensation.

Are Use It or Lose It Policies Legal

The legality of use it or lose it vacation policies varies depending on where you live. In some states, such as California and Montana, these policies are illegal under state law. In other states, such as New York and Texas, they are legal but must meet certain requirements.

In general, however, the legality of these policies hinges on whether they violate federal labor laws. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires that non-exempt employees (those who are eligible for overtime pay) be compensated for all hours worked, including vacation time. If a use it or lose it policy results in an employee not being compensated for unused vacation time, it could be considered a violation of the FLSA.

Alternatives to Use It or Lose It Policies

If you’re an employer looking for ways to encourage employees to take vacations without resorting to use it or lose it policies, there are several alternatives you can consider. One option is to allow employees to roll over unused vacation time into the next year. Another is to offer cash payouts for unused vacation time.

The Bottom Line

Use it or lose it vacation policies are legal in some states but illegal in others. Even if they are legal in your state, however, they may not be the best option for your company. Consider alternatives such as rollover options or cash payouts to encourage employees to take vacations without risking losing out on compensation.