Is When in Rome a Remake?

By Robert Palmer

Is When in Rome a Remake?

When it comes to movies, remakes have become a common occurrence in the film industry. One movie that often comes up in discussions about remakes is “When in Rome.”

But is “When in Rome” really a remake? Let’s take a closer look.

The Original Film

The original film titled “When in Rome” was released back in 1952. Directed by Clarence Brown, this romantic comedy starred actors Van Johnson and Paul Douglas. The story revolved around two American reporters who find themselves falling for the same woman while on assignment in Rome.

This classic film was well-received by audiences and critics alike for its witty dialogue, charming performances, and beautiful Italian setting.

The 2010 Version

Fast forward to 2010, and another film titled “When in Rome” hit the big screen. This version of the movie was directed by Mark Steven Johnson and starred Kristen Bell and Josh Duhamel.

While the title remained the same, the plot of the 2010 “When in Rome” differed significantly from its predecessor. In this modern reimagining, Bell’s character finds herself at a wedding in Rome where she impulsively takes coins from a magical fountain. This act unwittingly leads to several suitors falling head over heels for her upon their return to New York City.

Similarities and Differences

So, is the 2010 “When in Rome” a remake of the original?

  • While both films share the same title, they are essentially different stories with unique plots.
  • The only commonality between them is the romantic backdrop of Rome.
  • The 2010 version takes a more comedic and fantastical approach compared to the classic romantic comedy of the original.

In conclusion, “When in Rome” is not a remake in the traditional sense. It can be seen as a standalone film that pays homage to its predecessor by sharing the same title and exploring similar themes of love and romance.

So, whether you’re a fan of classic romance or modern romantic comedies, both versions of “When in Rome” offer their own unique charms and are worth checking out.