What Wine Won the Judgement of Paris?

By Robert Palmer

In 1976, a wine competition was held in Paris that would forever change the wine industry. The competition, known as the Judgement of Paris, pitted French wines against Californian wines in a blind taste test. The results shocked everyone in attendance and put California on the world wine map.

The Judgement of Paris: The Background

The Judgement of Paris was organized by a British wine merchant named Steven Spurrier. He invited nine French judges to participate in the event, which was held at the InterContinental Hotel in Paris on May 24, 1976.

The judges were asked to taste and rate ten Chardonnays and ten Cabernet Sauvignons – five from California and five from France. The results were supposed to reaffirm France’s position as the world’s leading producer of fine wines.

The Results

To everyone’s surprise, when the scores were tallied, a Californian wine had won both categories. The winning Chardonnay was from Chateau Montelena while the winning Cabernet Sauvignon came from Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars.

This result caused quite a stir in France as their long-standing reputation for producing superior wines had been called into question. However, it also gave California winemakers a newfound confidence and international recognition.

  • Chateau Montelena: This winery is located in Napa Valley and is known for its Chardonnay. The winning vintage from 1973 is now considered a classic and highly sought after by collectors.
  • Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars: This winery is also located in Napa Valley and produces Cabernet Sauvignon. Their winning vintage from 1973 is still produced today and remains one of their most popular offerings.

The Impact of the Judgement of Paris

The Judgement of Paris changed the wine industry in several ways. Firstly, it brought attention to California as a legitimate wine producing region. Prior to this event, most people associated quality wine with France, Italy, and Spain.

Secondly, it challenged the traditional notion that French wines were superior to all others. This opened up the market for other regions to gain recognition and respect for their wines.

Lastly, it gave American winemakers a sense of pride and validation for their hard work and dedication to producing high-quality wines. It also helped pave the way for the global recognition of New World wines in general.

Conclusion

The Judgement of Paris was a defining moment in the wine industry. It challenged long-held beliefs about wine quality and put California on the map as a legitimate producer of fine wines. Today, Chateau Montelena and Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars remain highly respected wineries that continue to produce award-winning wines.