Why Was Paris Green or Scheele’s Green So Toxic?

By Michael Ferguson

Paris Green, also known as Emerald Green or Scheele’s Green, was a popular pigment used in the 19th century for coloring everything from wallpaper to clothing. However, it was also notorious for its toxicity, leading to numerous health problems and even deaths. In this article, we’ll explore why Paris Green was so toxic and how it came to be used despite its dangers.

What is Paris Green?

Paris Green is a bright green pigment that was first discovered in 1814 by a Swiss chemist named Christian Friedrich Schönbein. It was later refined by a German chemist named Carl Wilhelm Scheele, which is why it’s sometimes called Scheele’s Green. Paris Green became popular as a dye and pigment due to its vibrant color and resistance to fading.

Why Was Paris Green So Toxic?

Despite its popularity, it soon became clear that Paris Green was incredibly toxic. The main reason for this toxicity is the presence of two highly poisonous compounds: copper acetoarsenite and copper acetate. These substances can cause a range of health problems when ingested or inhaled, including skin irritation, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, diarrhea, convulsions, coma, and even death.

How Did People Get Exposed to Paris Green?

Paris Green was used in many different products during the 19th century. It was commonly used to color textiles such as dresses and curtains.

It was also used as a pesticide on crops such as cotton and tobacco to protect them from insects. Additionally, it was used as a pigment in paints and wallpapers.

People could be exposed to Paris Green in several ways. Those who worked with the pigment directly were particularly at risk of inhaling or ingesting it accidentally. This included textile workers who handled dyed fabrics or wallpaper makers who mixed the pigment into paste.

Farmers who used Paris Green as a pesticide were also at risk of exposure. They could inhale the toxic dust while applying the pesticide or ingest it by consuming crops that had been treated with it.

Why Was Paris Green Still Used Despite Its Dangers?

Despite the well-known dangers of Paris Green, it continued to be used widely throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries. One reason for this was its effectiveness as a pesticide. It was one of the few substances available at the time that could effectively control crop pests.

Another reason was the lack of regulations around toxic substances during this time period. There were no laws in place to protect workers or consumers from exposure to dangerous chemicals like Paris Green.

It wasn’t until the early 20th century that governments began to regulate toxic substances more closely. In 1906, Congress passed the Pure Food and Drug Act, which required manufacturers to list dangerous ingredients on product labels.

Conclusion

Paris Green may have been a popular pigment in its time, but it came with significant risks to human health. Its toxicity was due to the presence of copper acetoarsenite and copper acetate, which can cause a range of health problems when ingested or inhaled.

Despite these dangers, it continued to be used widely until regulations were put in place to protect workers and consumers from exposure to toxic substances. Today, there are many safer alternatives available for coloring textiles and controlling pests, making Paris Green a cautionary tale about the importance of safety regulations when dealing with potentially harmful chemicals.