Why Was the Colony Resort Abandoned?

By Anna Duncan

The Colony Resort was one of the most popular vacation destinations in Florida during the 1950s and 1960s. However, for reasons that are still unclear, this beautiful resort eventually fell into disrepair and was abandoned. In this article, we will explore the history of the Colony Resort and what led to its eventual demise.

The History of the Colony Resort

The Colony Resort was built in 1947 by a wealthy businessman named Barron Gift Collier. Collier was a major figure in Southwest Florida’s development during the early 20th century and had a vision of creating a luxurious resort that would attract tourists from all over the world. The resort was located on an exclusive island in Sarasota Bay and boasted an impressive array of amenities, including a private beach, golf course, tennis courts, and yacht club.

The Glory Days

During its heyday in the 1950s and 1960s, the Colony Resort was considered one of the finest vacation destinations in Florida. Celebrities like Elvis Presley, Elizabeth Taylor, and Frank Sinatra were known to frequent the resort, which became famous for its lavish parties and high-end luxury.

However, despite its glamorous reputation, there were signs of trouble on the horizon for the Colony Resort. In the late 1960s, tourism began to decline in Florida as other destinations like Hawaii and California gained popularity. Additionally, changes in travel patterns meant that fewer people were interested in staying at large resorts like The Colony.

The Decline

By the early 1970s, The Colony Resort had begun to fall into disrepair. The owners struggled to keep up with maintenance costs as occupancy rates continued to decline. In 1979, Hurricane David caused extensive damage to the property that was never fully repaired.

The final nail in The Colony’s coffin came in 1982, when the resort was sold to a developer who had plans to demolish it and build condominiums on the site. Despite protests from local residents and preservationists, the resort was eventually torn down in 2007.

The Legacy of The Colony Resort

Though The Colony Resort may be gone, it is not forgotten. Many people look back on the resort’s glory days with fondness, and there are efforts underway to preserve its legacy. The Sarasota Architectural Foundation has designated The Colony as a historic landmark, and there are plans to create a museum on the site that will showcase the resort’s history and influence on Florida’s tourism industry.

The Lessons Learned

The story of The Colony Resort serves as a cautionary tale for those in the hospitality industry. It is a reminder that even the most luxurious and popular destinations can fall out of favor if they fail to adapt to changing times. As we move forward into an uncertain future, it is important for resorts and hotels to remain agile and responsive to evolving trends in travel and tourism.

  • Adaptation is key to survival
  • Maintain your property well
  • Listen to your customers’ needs

Conclusion

The Colony Resort was once a shining example of luxury and glamour in Florida’s tourism industry. However, changes in travel patterns, declining occupancy rates, and poor management ultimately led to its demise. Though it may be gone, its legacy lives on as a reminder that even the most successful businesses must remain vigilant in order to thrive.